Search for Justine Gotti Agnello and you’ll find pages calling her an actress, an author, a socialite, even John Gotti’s daughter. None of it is true.
Justine Gotti Agnello was the first child of Victoria Gotti, daughter of the late Gambino crime boss John Gotti, and Victoria’s then-husband Carmine Agnello. Sadly, she was stillborn. Her story is short, but it matters to her family, and it deserves to be told accurately.
This article explains who Justine was, how she fits into the Gotti family, and why so much false information about her exists online.
Who Was Justine Gotti Agnello?
Justine was the daughter of Victoria Gotti and Carmine Agnello. According to People, nine months after Victoria married Agnello in 1984, the couple lost their daughter, Justine, who was stillborn.
Victoria and Carmine married on December 9, 1984, which would place Justine’s birth around 1985. No exact date has been made public, and the family has never shared further details.
Because she died at birth, Justine had no career, no public life, and no relationships of her own. She is remembered mainly through her mother’s story.
Family Background: Parents and Siblings
Her Mother, Victoria Gotti
Victoria Gotti is an American writer and television personality, best known as the daughter of John Gotti. She worked as a columnist at the New York Post and wrote several novels, including The Senator’s Daughter (1997), I’ll Be Watching You (1998), Superstar (2000) and Hot Italian Dish (2006).
She became a household name through the A&E reality series Growing Up Gotti, which followed her life as a single mother raising three sons.
Her Father, Carmine Agnello
Justine’s father is Carmine Agnello, a Queens scrap-metal businessman with ties to the Gambino family. Carmine married Victoria in 1984 despite her parents’ disapproval. The relationship was turbulent. In 2003, while Agnello was in jail, Victoria divorced him on grounds of constructive abandonment. He later remarried in 2008 and has a son from that marriage, born in 2009.
Her Grandfather, John Gotti
Justine’s maternal grandfather was John Gotti, the head of the Gambino crime family, nicknamed the “Teflon Don” and “Dapper Don.” He died in a Missouri federal prison in 2002 at age 61. It’s worth being clear on this point, since some sites wrongly list Justine as his daughter. She was his granddaughter.
Her Brothers: Carmine, John and Frank
After losing Justine, Victoria and Carmine had three sons:
- Carmine Gotti Agnello Jr., born April 4, 1986. He later pursued a brief music career after the reality show ended.
- John Gotti Agnello, born May 8, 1987. He married his longtime girlfriend, Alina Sanchez, in 2015 at Oheka Castle on Long Island, and has children of his own.
- Frank Gotti Agnello, born April 12, 1990, who published a fitness book, Gotti Diet, after the show ended.
All three brothers appeared on Growing Up Gotti. Justine would have been their older sister.
Justine Gotti Agnello Family Table
| Relation | Name | Key Detail |
|---|---|---|
| Self | Justine Gotti Agnello | Stillborn first child, around 1985 |
| Mother | Victoria Gotti | Author, former New York Post columnist, Growing Up Gotti star |
| Father | Carmine Agnello | Married Victoria in 1984; divorced 2003 |
| Brother | Carmine Gotti Agnello Jr. | Born April 4, 1986 |
| Brother | John Gotti Agnello | Born May 8, 1987; married Alina Sanchez in 2015 |
| Brother | Frank Gotti Agnello | Born April 12, 1990 |
| Grandfather | John Gotti | Gambino family boss; died in 2002 |
Why Justine Gotti Agnello Became a Public Search
If Justine never lived a public life, why do so many people search her name? There are two main reasons.
The 2019 Lifetime Movie
In 2019, Lifetime aired Victoria Gotti: My Father’s Daughter, starring Chelsea Frei as Victoria and Maurice Benard as John Gotti. Victoria narrated, co-wrote and executive produced the film.
The movie included Justine’s stillbirth, but that wasn’t Victoria’s original plan. She told People she fought hard with Lifetime executives to keep the death of her first child out of the film. She later said the moment was handled tastefully. For many viewers, this was the first time they had heard of Justine, which sent them searching for her name.
Auto-Generated “Biography” Pages
The second reason is less innocent. Once a name starts trending, low-quality sites rush out AI-written or recycled biographies. In Justine’s case, they’ve produced a long list of contradictions: different birth years (1957, 1964, 1986), careers as an actress, singer or author, a fake memoir, a supposed marriage to Carmine Agnello, and even a made-up shooting incident.
These pages often confuse Justine with her mother, Victoria, who really is an author, really did marry Carmine Agnello, and really did appear on reality TV. Some even mix her up with relatives on the Gotti side of the family. If a page describes Justine as an adult, it is not accurate.
The Personal Side of the Story
Behind the search results is a real loss. Victoria was in her early twenties and newly married when her first pregnancy ended in stillbirth. She went on to raise three sons, and she has described them as her greatest accomplishments.
Victoria’s reluctance to show Justine’s death on screen says a lot. Even decades later, it was a private grief she didn’t want turned into entertainment. That’s a useful reminder for anyone writing or reading about her: Justine’s story is a family’s loss, not tabloid material.
Recent Public Visibility
Justine herself has no public presence, but her name resurfaces whenever her family makes headlines. That happened again in 2025 and 2026.
In November 2025, it was reported that Victoria had chronic kidney disease and needed a transplant, with her son Carmine as the donor. In August 2026, Carmine Agnello Jr. began a 15-month federal sentence for COVID-related fraud at FCI Fairton in New Jersey, after delays tied to the planned kidney transplant, which had not taken place.
These stories renewed interest in the Gotti-Agnello family tree, which in turn brought more searches for Justine.
FAQs About Justine Gotti Agnello
Who was Justine Gotti Agnello?
Justine Gotti Agnello was the first child of Victoria Gotti and Carmine Agnello. She was stillborn around 1985, about nine months after her parents’ 1984 wedding.
Was Justine Gotti Agnello John Gotti’s daughter?
No. She was John Gotti’s granddaughter, through his daughter Victoria.
Was Justine Gotti Agnello an actress or author?
No. Because she was stillborn, she never had a career. Claims that she was an actress, singer or author come from unreliable sites, often confusing her with her mother, Victoria.
Who are Justine Gotti Agnello’s siblings?
She had three younger brothers: Carmine Gotti Agnello Jr., John Gotti Agnello and Frank Gotti Agnello, all known from Growing Up Gotti.
Who were Justine Gotti Agnello’s parents?
Her parents were Victoria Gotti, a writer and former New York Post columnist, and Carmine Agnello, a Queens businessman. They divorced in 2003.
Was Justine shown in the Lifetime movie about Victoria Gotti?
Yes. Her stillbirth is depicted in Victoria Gotti: My Father’s Daughter (2019), although Victoria initially wanted that scene left out.
Why is there so much conflicting information about Justine Gotti Agnello?
Most conflicting details come from auto-generated biography sites. Reliable outlets such as People and Biography.com agree that Justine was stillborn.
